Why did hermoine not help dobby

Why did hermoine not help dobby. Hermione is not a medical witch. I imagine even if they managed to fix the wound with magic (none of Harry, Ron and Hermione are Healers, so they'd have to waste time getting a Healer), it'd probably already be too late because Dobby lost a lot of blood and they aren't likely to have Blood-Replenishing Potions on them. -BB. That's great and all, but I'm left confused; When does Hermione get a scar reading 'Mudblood' on he Professor Dumbledore agrees to let the dismissed house-elves Dobby and Winky work at Hogwarts, and even agrees to pay Dobby. Dobby manages to apparate with Harry, Ron, Hermione and Griphook before Lord Voldemort arrives, but Dobby is fatally wounded by Bellatrix. Pushing Harry roughly aside, he knelt over Malfoy, drew his wand, and traced it over the deep wounds Harry’s curse had made, muttering an incantation that sounded almost Mar 26, 2023 · Dobby's death was used to create a sense of hopelessness in the viewer as the most lovable creature in the entire series was killed off by the evil that Ron, Harry and Hermione must face. She couldnt do anything. Did she even have the Dittany? IIRC the snatchers took most of their stuff. However, Dobby returned and sent the crystal chandelier falling to the floor. He looked rather scary when angry so Harry decided right there that he'd always try to do anything asked of by Dobby if not to receive that look again. Sep 7, 2015 · I would just like to point out that there is an additional reason why Hermione didn't immediately hand over the wand at Gringotts: it would have been out of character. A. in First of all, it's worth pointing out that Ron isn't stupid. Bellatrix then held her short knife to Hermione's throat in threat, and Harry and Ron surrendered their wands to Draco. Although she might not have had anything to help Dobby, she could have at least looked instead of standing there. May 9, 2020 · When Harry first asked Dobby to make him the promise, Dobby put on a huge smile but he technically didn't respond to the statement. Dobby the house-elf is freed from service to the Malfoy family Chaos in the campground after the Quidditch World Cup Bartemius Crouch sacks his house-elf, Winky Hermione founds S. Nov 19, 2017 · By name, Harry Potter might be the de facto hero of the novels, but Hermione was just as much a hero in her own right. Harry calls out for her to do something out of misplaced hope that Hermione will know something that can help Dobby. I mean it's an okay allegory. All of these things combined meant she couldn't help. " When he is dying in the books, the last words that he manages to get out are "Harry Potter. K. May not even have been effective on house elves. However, Hermione, who is responsible for administering the potion, lacks the knowledge and resources at the time to address the severity of Dobby's injury. Oct 16, 2017 · In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Bellatrix was relieved of her wand by Dobby at Malfoy Manor. Ron disarmed Bellatrix as soon as he entered the room, prompting All they to say, Hermione probably knew whether or not her parents would go. Ironing his hands, and hitting Aug 3, 2016 · See remarks on Harry's reaction to thoughts of Hermione, above. The Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare (S. Also note that Dobby is dropping yet another hint about the He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named issue. Overall, Hermione's relationship with the house elves seems like a pretty weird and poorly thought out part of the novels. g. The first meeting of Dumbledore’s Army Mar 17, 2016 · The movement to help them is given the humorous name of "S. Sorry if it doesn't make sense , it's my first post. Dobby kept hurting himself in numerous ways, e. She lacked the skills to do much more advanced magical healing, and likely knew that this situation exceeded anything she was capable of fixing. Sep 12, 2020 · It’s unknown how and why elves started serving wizard families, but J. Mar 10, 2024 · However, even though their relationship was crucial to the films and even stronger in the books, there's still the mystery of why Dobby wanted to help Harry in the first place. At the end of that school year, after Harry had Jun 20, 2018 · @AnthonyGrist Dobby was ultimately trying to help Harry (by keeping him safe from danger). She can’t heal Dobby. Clearly Harry (and Ron, and probably Neville, too) would have died early into Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone had Hermione Granger, Muggle-born daughter of dentists, not been in the picture. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing – even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. In 1992, he tried to warn Harry Potter of the plot to have the Chamber of Secrets reopened which he came to know via the contact between his masters and Lord Voldemort. The entire subplot was so thin that it was almost completely dropped from the films, with no real effect on the story. Harry runs into Percy Weasley , who praises his flying in the Quidditch match, and says that he earned Gryffindor fifty points, and the lead for House Cup. Why did Harry not tell Hermione that Dobby was the only one cleaning the Gryffindor common room? Question S. "That is not safe Mar 15, 2017 · @T. Hermione began attending Hogwarts in 1991 and was Sorted into Gryffindor House. Well, I mean, Dobby was hit by a knife in the chest (iirc). Features May 16, 2024 · Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. Hates Draco Malfoy In Harry Potter Jan 22, 2015 · Because conceivably, the elves belong to Hogwarts as an institution, not to the staff. Mar 18, 2024 · In The Deathly Hallows, Dobby sneaks into Malfoy Manor in order to save Harry, Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, Garrick Ollivander, and Luna Lovegood as they are being kept there as prisoners "Dobby it's alright I always tell him he can borrow things any time he needs them so don't worry about it" he said shocked when Dobby looked angry. I'm glad the tiny fat scheming long nosed money grabbing goblins agreed . Dobby interfered with Harry’s life a number of times that year with less […] Harry hurries to Gryffindor tower to tell Ron and Hermione about Colin and Dobby, but they aren’t there. I mean technically shouldn't she be happy that winky became free. May 2, 2018 · On Wednesday, she apologised for killing Dobby, the house-elf freed after a trick by Harry Potter who went on to save him, Luna Lovegood, Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger, before they were turned And because of Dobby and Kreacher, Ron finally understands the importance of the house elves leading to Ron and Hermione's first kiss. I mean, Harry was screaming for her to help him, she could have tried to help. Including to the students. E. . But, also, she was barely able to stand after what happened to her in Malfoy Manor. Later, Bellatrix We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Sep 18, 2019 · After class, Hermione asks Lockhart to sign a note for a library book to help her understand something in one of his works; he readily signs it, then offers to provide Harry advice on being a Quidditch Seeker. [1] Bellatrix held this knife to Hermione Granger's throat in the spring of 1998 in Malfoy Manor, after having tortured Hermione into unconsciousness, prompting Harry Potter and Ron Weasley to rush to her rescue once Dobby the house-elf freed them from the dungeons below. “Dobby wants to save Harry Potter’s life! Better sent home, grievously injured, than remain here, sir! Dobby only wanted Harry Potter hurt enough to be sent home!” Thus, Harry is telling Dobby, perhaps slightly in jest, that he is better off without Dobby trying to save him. Hermione is mostly ridiculed for her efforts to help them, even by "good" characters like Ron. It may have been inferred but Dobby never made a direct promise to his friend. Jan 2, 2023 · Every tragic death has a purpose, and whilst Dobby's is undoubtedly one of the most emotional, it's also one of the most important and meaningful. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. It's possible to care about two things but only act on one. Dobby is thrilled with his new situation, but Winky is deeply ashamed of being a free house-elf (GF21). The Boy Who Lived first met Dobby in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets while he was living with the Dursleys. As they leave the kitchen, Hermione hopes that if the other Elves see how happy Dobby is as a free Elf, they may eventually adopt the idea. She possessed a brilliant academic mind and proved to be a gifted Jul 7, 2022 · Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. Just my thoughts. Minister Hermione Jean[28] Granger (b. His masters were Dark Wizards who treated him cruelly. Rowling did give a bit of backstory to the elves’ arrival at Hogwarts. The funeral of Dobby was held in March of 1998 in the garden of Shell Cottage on the outskirts of Tinworth, Cornwall, to pay respects to the late house-elf. While the boys were put in the cellar with Luna Lovegood, Dean Thomas and Ollivander, Hermione was tortured for answers by Bellatrix Lestrange. He is actually killed by a member of the Malfoy household when he Bellatrix Lestrange owned a short knife made of silver. Why didn’t Hermoine help save Dobby like she did earlier when Ron was injured at the ministry. In fact, Dobby saved him on multiple other instances before Deathly Hallows, such as giving him gillyweed for the Triwizard Tournament May 2, 2018 · Every year, on the anniversary of the Battle of Hogwarts, J. infiltrated Gringotts. Dobby (28 June (year unknown) – March 1998) was a male house-elf who served the Malfoy family. Aug 2, 2015 · Why didn't Dobby or Harry use Healing Magic to treat Dobby. It generally makes Hermione look incompetent and it sends the message that oppressed people are happy and want to be oppressed, despite initially focusing on the only elf ever to be mistreated and to dislike his master or want freedom. She first appeared in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (1997), as a first-year student on her way to Hogwarts. Dec 25, 2023 · This not only suggests Harry's importance to Dobby, it echoes the first words Dobby ever speaks to Harry: "Harry Potter!" . Jul 11, 2021 · “Not kill you, sir, never kill you!” said Dobby, shocked. Apr 13, 2017 · This question contains the following image, and asks why Ron has a series of scars on his arms. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Why did Hermione say she had been sort of right about the Half-Blood Prince?, How did Harry know that Dumbledore was dead?, What did Harry Learn from Professor Trelawney? and more. Harry was always true to them he arguably never disrepair the boys he even gave dobby the sock to prank Malfoy Hermione went to hard but harry was always there saving the world and being a kind person. Feb 20, 2024 · The Tragic Truth: Why Hermione Couldn't Save Dobby • The Tragic Truth • Unveiling the heartbreaking reason why Hermione Granger couldn't save Dobby the house Harry stunned Lucius, who did not have a wand to repel the spell, and then rolled behind a sofa to avoid spells from Narcissa, Draco and Greyback. Ron cared about the passing of Dobby, but Hermione needed right now help. Hermione Granger (/ h ɜːr ˈ m aɪ ə n i ˈ ɡ r eɪ n dʒ ər / hur-MY-ə-nee GRAYN-jər) is a fictional character in the Harry Potter series of novels by J. The wand was in Hermione's possession when Harry and Co. Sep 21, 2016 · Hermione was not an experienced healer. Jul 7, 2022 · Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It's not going to do much to heal a vital organ before the person dies. Dec 24, 2023 · Dobby was a house-elf, for years indentured to the Malfoy family, until his admiration for Harry Potter goaded him into trying to warn Harry against coming to school in his second year because he knew what Lucius was planning with the diary. MORE: Why Barty Crouch Jr. "Not - not He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, sir -" Dobby explains why this remark wasn't quite a lie in the last chapter, "Dobby's Reward". "It's that Why did Hermione not help Dobby when he was dying? Originally Answered: Why didn’t Hermione help Dobby when his life was in danger in Deathly Hallows 1? She was in shock from being tortured by Bellatrix, if you remember from the books and movies she was really weak, she couldn’t do anything just witness the death happen of Dobby. ) was an organisation founded in 1994 by Hermione Granger in response to what she saw as gross injustice in the treatment of house-elves at the 1994 Quidditch World Cup. "You've just ruined the punch line of my Japanese golfer Aug 4, 2019 · Dobby's death is incredibly tragic, but this small detail might make it even more so. Jan 2, 2019 · Harry, Ron and Hermione’s luck ran out and they found themselves captured and helpless at Malfoy Manor. At the age of eleven, she learned about her magical nature and was accepted into Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. He's not as book smart or as Type-A as Hermione, but he does have common sense. Rowling. May 8, 2024 · Originally Answered: Why didnt Hermione help Dobby when his life was in danger in Deathly Hallows 1? She was in shock from being tortured by Bellatrix, if you remember from the books and movies she was really weak, she couldnt do anything just witness the death happen of Dobby. Dobby was murdered by Death Eater Bellatrix Lestrange in the course of rescuing several prisoners from Malfoy Manor. In deathly hallows, the scene where they were all escaping from Malfoy manor with Dobby’s help, and bellatrix throws a knife as they were disapparating, as they get to the cottage where Bill and Fleur were staying in, Harry discovers dobby was Apr 15, 2023 · Attempts to save Dobby include applying Essence of Dittany, a potion known for accelerating wound healing. K. He came to know this via the contact between his masters and Lord Voldemort. Rowling apologizes for killing off a character in the "Harry Potter" series. Rowling revealed that elves were brought to Hogwarts by Helga Hufflepuff , in hopes to give them good work conditions – meaning getting paid and not being abused, which is what happened in most By starting SPEW Hermione made it her goal to free all house-elves whether they want to or not, but when crouch dismissed winky (which was wrong ) Hermione protested it . The characters of Bill Weasley, Charlie Weasley, Ludo Bagman, Winky, Narcissa Malfoy, and Bertha Jorkins are all absent, as well as Dobby who was supposed to help Harry obtain Gillyweed for the second task. “The door banged open behind Harry and he looked up, terrified: Snape had burst into the room, his face livid. Why couldn t they save Dobby with Magic? Also, Dobby’s injury was … Why did Hermione not save Dobby? Read More » We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. His masters were Dark wizards who treated him cruelly. And despite Hermione's comment about his limited emotional range, I would say he has more "people skills" than she does. 19 September 1979)[1] was an English Muggle-born[3] witch born to Mr and Mrs Granger. A psychiatrist forcibly restraining and sedating a manic patient who wants to hurl himself off a high ledge (because he thinks he can fly like Superman) is still trying to help the patient (by keeping him alive) even though the patient may disagree in his current (manic) state of mind. [1] Having been deeply upset at the treatment and general prospects of house-elves, both in Hogwarts and the rest of the wizarding world, Hermione set up S. It's called it's more complicated than that. Dumbledore originally offered Dobby ten Galleons a week plus time off,… Read More Dobby (28 June (year unknown), - March 1998) was a house-elf who served the Malfoy family. Note that just before entering Gringotts, Hermione-Bellatrix greeted a man, and this had been considered by Ron and Harry as something the real Bellatrix would have never done: Why did Harry ask Dobby not to save him? Harry loves Dobby and knows his enemy is too strong and powerful, so harry is always a guy who is willing to take any danger and challenge even if he doesn’t care about his life, but at the same time he cares about the lives of others, so harry doesn’t want to engage some in risk. Dec 24, 2020 · This was achieved by "putting aside" all the components of the novel which did not directly relate to Harry and his journey. Even then she was just tortured into unconsciousness, was at the cottage before Dobby and Harry left Malfoy manor, and dittany isn't a cure-all. Nov 20, 2018 · She says Ludo Bagman is a bad wizard, but will not divulge why, claiming she always keeps her masters' secrets. There’s a good chance that they would have refused unless she went with them, which she was determined not to do, so ultimately I think modifying their memories was the best option she had available to her. " That means the first and last words that Dobby said in the books are Harry Potter. Why did he now look angry. Also from Deathly Hallows, speaking about Ron but applies to Dobby as well-" 'It's all I feel safe doing,' said Hermione shakily. P. His burial was conducted by Harry Potter and his eulogy was given by Luna Lovegood, though the others he rescued also gave Apr 3, 2022 · A fight ensues, but Harry, Ron and Dobby disarm all the Death Eaters (Harry wrestles the wands away from Draco Malfoy). Dec 25, 2018 · Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby. That's why he had to stage what led to Dobby suggesting to Harry the gillyweed. Dobby reminding her she no longer has a master only sends her into fresh paroxysms of tears. Not at all a plot hole. This year, it's Dobby, the house-elf. He goes to look for them, hurt that they aren’t interested in his recovery. On the first Hogsmeade weekend, Harry and Hermione found the D. Sar Barty Jr actually explains how proud Harry was; his biggest fear was that Harry was too proud to ask for help. It really sets the scene for the coming storm of Deathly Hallows Part 2, marking a turning point into the darker side of Harry Potter. W is all about improving the lives of house elves, so I feel like Hermione would want to know that she was inadvertently making Dobby’s life harder since none of the other house elves wanted to clean the Gryffindor common room anymore. Observe that House Elves in hogwarts will give food to students even if it wasn't directed by the staff (James Potter, as per Dumbledore, used the Invisibility Cloak to sneak food. While still in the Malfoys' service, Dobby told Harry that "Dobby is used to death threats" and that he "gets them five times a day" at Malfoy Manor . W. In 1992, he disobeyed his masters and tried to warn Harry Potter of the plot to have the Chamber of Secrets reopened. When Harry first meets Dobby, the house elf's first words are "Harry Potter. qfmkgv fkba uftl zeww otm gcvkrj ggwv dsejqzkh awbxq cgq